|
Post by graham on Sept 30, 2019 6:43:03 GMT
Anyone watch this last night? They announced the winning shot, i.e. the one that will adorn the cover, it's a shot of a fieldmouse sat inside a rotting apple, great shot until you realise it was set up in the studio.
I thought the whole essence of Countryfile was "outdoors"? You wait and sometimes have a split second to get the shot, you might be lucky, or you might not be. This shot was set up under lamps, in what looked like a terrarium containing one rotting apple and several fieldmice, she waited for a mouse to climb into the apple then fired off several bursts, of which she presumably chose the best one as her entry.
Apparently the competition rules state that this is acceptable as long as you declare it was a studio shot, but the voting public, many of whom will buy the calendar won't know this, and will assume the winner got her shot by crawling through an orchard in the rotting apples, camera poised ready for the shot, not that I've ever seen a fieldmouse in an orchard anyway. I'm lucky that I live very close to miles of open countryside, and often take my camera out with me. A few weeks ago, pre harvest, a Roe deer stuck its head up above the wheat and I had half a second to get the shot, which I didn't. Surely that's the essence of what should be an entry, assuming of course that you get your shot.
I've entered the competition several times over the years, never got anywhere, and now I suspect I might know why.
Thoughts?
|
|
|
Post by jargon on Sept 30, 2019 11:08:13 GMT
Hi Graham I didn't see this program and I don't know the rules of this competition or exactly what its aims are apart from raising money for children in need. Personally I really appreciate a totally wild photo and the craft, skill and dedication that can go in to getting them. OK sometimes you can get lucky and just walk on to a photo, but you still have to be out and about to get the photograph. If the aim of the program is to get people out and about then I wouldn't want a studio shot A friend of set himself the task of photographing a Nightjar at night, I was fortunate to have the privilege of being with him when he realised his ambition. The trials and tribulations of getting this photo make a good story in themselves and only add to the value of that final photo for me. I'd be interested in seeing your entries if you'd like to post them or pm them to me, you would have been up against a huge number of people so don't get despondent Other big photographic competitions can have issues too www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/news/2018/april/wildlife-photographer-of-the-year-image-disqualified.htmlRegards John
|
|
|
Post by Jeff on Sept 30, 2019 14:51:28 GMT
A colleague at work got 3rd place a couple of years ago after moving to Devon, she takes some wonderful photos
|
|
|
Post by christoff on Sept 30, 2019 17:04:26 GMT
Mine was rejected too, don't know why!! Maybe a Banner Shot contender DSCF2435 by christoffiw, on Flickr
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Sept 30, 2019 17:04:32 GMT
Missed last nights programme-will download it on catch-up- I get the Countryfile Calendar every year- looking forward to seeing the photographs which have been selected. Your colleague as you say must be a good photographer Jeff to get 3rd place out of all the photos submitted. The cover photo mentioned by Graham albeit a set up shot must take a lot of patience- more than I've got, very clever indeed. One thing about the Calendar is it is for a good cause, and long may that be the case.
Regards
AM
|
|
|
Post by graham on Sept 30, 2019 18:48:21 GMT
It is indeed a great cause AM and like you, I always buy it. Countryfile is an outdoor programme and I can imagine that hundreds 9f entrants who possibly braved bad weather, got cold and wet to get their shot were beaten by a person who to all intent was in the comfort of their own four walls.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Oct 1, 2019 13:44:00 GMT
It is indeed a great cause AM and like you, I always buy it. Countryfile is an outdoor programme and I can imagine that hundreds 9f entrants who possibly braved bad weather, got cold and wet to get their shot were beaten by a person who to all intent was in the comfort of their own four walls. Point taken- but the guy or lady who won the comp was very clever the way he/she obtained the photograph and you have covered the rules in your post- which do not say anything about it being inside or out just the essence of the countryside. Christoffs photo would have been rejected albeit very funny as it is obviously in a zoo, or on safari somewhere. Anyway back to aviation. AM
|
|